Editorial Review Product Description Read by 3 cassettes, 5 hrs. 15 min.
A suspenseful, richly layered first novel that asks: How much do we owe the people we love?
THE DIVE FROM CLAUSEN'S PIER will speak to all those who have ever thought about leaving when they knew they should stay, anyone who has ever felt trapped, not only by circumstance, but by the strength of their own love, Carrie Bell has lived in Wisconsin all her life.She's had the same best friend, the same good relationship with her mother, the same boyfriend, for as long as anyone can remember.But when her fiance, Mike is paralyzed by a tragic accident, Carrie has to question everything she thought she knew about herself and about the meaning of home.
Ann Packer has written a morally complex, deeply satisfying novel about the desire to live fully and the conflict between who we want to be to others and who we must be for ourselves.A magnificent debut from a remarkable new talent.Amazon.com Review Carrie Bell is the worst person in the world. Or so she would have you think. In the gripping, carefully paced debut novel of personal epiphany, The Dive from Clausen's Pier, by O. Henry Award winner Ann Packer, Carrie's very survival is dependent upon her leaving her fiancé, even after he dives into shallow water at a Memorial Day picnic and becomes paralyzed. Things hadn't been going so well for the Madison, Wisconsin, high school and college sweethearts. Carrie knew, deep down, that she wasn't going to become Mrs. Michael Mayer. But expectations and pressure from all sides--his family, her mother, her best friend Jamie, Mike's best friend Rooster--force Carrie to shut herself up in her room and sew outfits of her own design as if in a trance. Then one night she slips out of the only universe she's ever known. Many hours later she finds herself on the doorstep of a high school classmate living in Manhattan. Carrie's adventures in the city--quirky roommates and a new romance with an older,emotionally impenetrable man--confuse her in her quest both to forgive herself and to embark on a career in fashion design. Packer writes in a convincing voice and packs a lot into this novel; she infuses Carrie with enough humanity and smarts to choose her own version of "happily ever after." --Emily Russin ... Read more Customer Reviews (418)
Grabbed me from the first paragraph and I couldn't put it down
This is my first time reading an Ann Packer novel. And The Dive from Clausen's Pier is Ann Packer's first novel. I was hooked from the first paragraph, which is just the way I like a book to be, it sucks you in and you just know it's going to be an easy and enjoyable read.
The question posed by Ann in this novel is a terrible one that no one ever wants to have to answer. What do you do if you start to grow away from your partner, and then they are injured in a terrible accident? Do you stay out of pity, or do you walk away and try and shape a new life buried under the weight of guilt?
Ann deals with this question and the answer in this beautifully written book and I found myself unable to put it down. I wanted to know what would become of Carrie, and of Mike. How her friends and family would react to the choices that she makes. And how the relationship with an enigmatic man helps Carrie answer the questions whirling round her own head and help her to decide on the path she wants to take in life.
I'm putting this one onto the 5 star bookshelf and will look out for Ann's other novels.
Could have done without it
Starts off ok, then muddles along endlessly.Its ok but I wouldn't waste time reading again.
Four Stars
I really enjoyed this novel.It received mixed reviews and I completely understand why. Before reading this novel, I read all the reviews, and was sure that I would find Carrie and her decision to head to NYC despicable.Without going into any specifics of the plot, I was surprised to find that I did not completely hate her.I did find many of her decisions questionable, and I had to remind myself numerous times that she was 23 and completely lost in her own life. Her last decision of the novel was the only decision she made that I agreed with, and I applauded her for coming to the conclusion that she did.I found Carrie somewhat difficult to relate to, as I have never had the means to just up and move on a whim, and then not work for a year.Sometimes when I was reading the novel, and Carrie was describing how she spent her day, I found myself thinking "Stop moping around and get a job."The one character that I really loved was Mike.The descriptions of him absolutely broke my heart, and I found myself dangerously close to weeping sometimes while reading his scenes.
I thought that this novel was well-written and interesting.I did not necessarily agree with the way she portrayed Mid-westerners, however, as stodgy and boring.Having lived in both New York and Chicago, I found her description of mid-westerners inaccurate.Nonetheless, I keep in mind that Packer was writing from Carrie's perspective, and maybe this is just how Carrie viewed the midwest.I give this book four stars, because even though I was unable to relate to Carrie and sometimes found her annoying, I really did enjoy reading the story, and it will stay with me for along time.
A message of acceptance
I just wanted to add one comment to the other reviews.When the main character Carrie comes home and asks her mother if she's a bad person because she left her fiance after he suffered a debilitating accident, her mother responds by saying "It's not very helpful to regard your choices as a series of right or wrong choices.They don't define you as much as you define them".Maybe I have a lot of unresolved guilt, but I liked this thought so well I text messaged it to myself and I read it from time to time.
Other than that, the book kept my interest even though I didn't particularly like any of the main characters, and other than the quote above, Carrie's mother in particular was really flat - unflappable, always sensible, never worried, never harried, never changing or growing.Maybe that was a statement about small town life and why Carrie needed to leave, but I don't know people like that and reading about them is sort of "yeah right".
Choices
This is the story of one year in the life of Carrie Bell, a young midwestern woman.The writer goes deep into the lady's thoughts, actions,and feelings, her relationships with all her friends, her ambitions and the two men important in her life.
Carrue is a twenty three year old who has always lived a conservative life; she graduated from high school, obtained a college degree, dated the same boy since her early teens and had the same best friend since second grade.She was born and grew up in the city of Madison, Wisconson.Now she feels she needs to enlarge her life and choices.She has loved sewing, been fascinated with different types of fabrics and pours over books of clothing designing.
Then comes the tragic accident; Mike Meyers dives from Clausen Pier and is left a paraplegic.He spends weeks in the hospital.Carrie feels it is her fault; Mike was trying toimpress her.Carrie does not want to rush into marriage, her feelings for Mike has cooled.She wants to try other options before she settles down.And she is young and has her whole life ahead outside of Madison, Wisconsin.So she does.
Overwhelmed, and who can blame her, she hops in her car and drives all the way to New York.She has a gay man friend who has invited her to come to the Big Apple and stay and she does.Carrie meets most of his friends and finds a lover who she had metwhile Kilroy was visiting Madison.Carrie signs up for expensive clothing designing courses which she loves.But Kilroy is a strange one.He dislikes all of his family because of a reason that happened many years ago. For this he cannot forgive them.He wants nothing to do with any of them.He loves Carrie and wants to marry her.He is seven years younger than Carrie's mother.
Carrie goes back and forth in her mind, missing Mike, comparing him with Kilroy, missing her
friends in Madison, comparing them with the New York friends.When she goes back to visit Madison she misses the excitement of New York; in New York she misses the
lakes, parks and comparative quiet of Madison.
Finally Carrie makes her choice.Whether it is the right one or not is up to thereader to decide.
... Read more
|